The professor who manages to piss off colleagues and lobbyists alike

Fredrik Nyström is slightly annoyed. And a little fed up.
He usually is when I meet him. Usually a few times a year - at conferences, seminars, lectures and debates. Our meetings take place at events where the use of one of the world's most controversial substances, nicotine, takes centre stage. Often with Fredrik Nyström as the star of the debate.

This time, he has just stepped off the stage at a seminar organised by the We Are Innovation organisation in London. He has been talking about his new book "Lighten the load on your shoulders" - a small scientific journal in a kind of war against contemporary clean-living idealism. Nicotine has its own chapter in the book. Fredrik Nyström's research indicates that pleasure plays an important role in individual health - and that those who use nicotine need not be ashamed of it.

"The important thing is that you don't smoke the nicotine. There is plenty of evidence that snus or vaping is not really a major risk. But not many of my colleagues - or medical students - seem to realise that. Frustrating, to say the least."

Travelling around the world

As I said. A little tired. Fredrik Nyström is not only a writer but also a doctor and has been employed at Linköping University Hospital for 30 years. As a professor of internal medicine, he trains medical students and conducts research. But in recent years he has also travelled around the world, often speaking at various seminars on harm reduction for smokers. Snus and nicotine is one of his specialities.

"It's the effects of Swedish snus on the body that I've looked at most. But I also find e-cigarettes exciting. I dare say that these purer forms of nicotine use can actually do more good than harm for many people. If you look at it from a broader health perspective, those who use snus and enjoy it often feel better than those who have given up nicotine completely. Why is this so? Nicotine barely affects cortisol levels, but at the same time increases the ability to focus, helps some people relax and helps control hunger. So what's the problem? Apart from the addiction, of course, but that's another matter," he says.

Breaking the norm - with science

This somewhat controversial position on nicotine use is based on studies he has published in various medical journals over the years. These studies have looked not only at snus, but also at other substances such as alcohol and high-fat foods. He summarises many of his conclusions in his book "Lighten the load on your shoulders". The book is a bit like a thorn in the side of everyone who adopts the "dietary circle model" (Fredrik Nyström prefers to talk about Mediterranean food and nuts) and other general health advice from the National Board of Health and Welfare.

And to top it all off, Mr Nyström points a pretty clear finger at the anti-tobacco movement. He is sometimes asked who is funding the studies. Then, as I said, he gets annoyed.

"I've been doing research with leftover money from other larger projects, just because I'm interested in this. The subjects have been students who have volunteered almost for free and they have been enthusiastic to participate. But these are studies that have made it through the eye of the needle, been reviewed and published. That's all that counts in the end," he says when the subject comes up after his chat on stage has turned into a mingle with the audience.

Smoke-free nicotine - a hot potato

This particular event takes place at the same time as the conference E-cigarette Summit in London. Quit Like Sweden is the organisation We Are Innovation's project to spread what it calls the "Swedish model" for smoke-free living around the world. Responsible for the event is Suely Castro. And she sees Mr Nyström's research as confirmation of how access to smokeless nicotine can transform the lives of both individuals and entire communities.

"Sweden is a leading example of how harm reduction can work in practice. It is virtually the only country in the world where smoking is disappearing, while nicotine use remains high. I was curious to know why this has happened. Obviously, snus, e-cigs and nicotine pouches are innovations that have been crucial. Because it is only in Sweden that these products are available in every other shop. You Swedes have opted out of the deadly alternative yourselves and the industry - and more importantly, the convenience stores - have responded. It's a success story."

New Zealand is also highlighted as an example. There, e-cigarettes have in recent years functioned like snus in Sweden.

"Smoking is falling at a rapid pace, while vejp is increasing at a similar rate. It's amazing to see, especially as it also applies to the most economically vulnerable - the indigenous Maori people, who used to smoke far more than others. Now they are vaping more and smoke less"

Suely has invited journalists from across Europe to the event and hopes that the message will lead to at least a few articles on the importance of harm reduction in the nicotine market.

"I want to create platforms for interactions, meetings, that's what I can do well. But I know that this topic is sensitive. It's about big money, it's about ideology, it's about changing the tobacco companies and public health authorities and at the same time politicians' views on nicotine use and addiction." says Suely Castro.

Big busieness - medicines with nicotine

Coming from the pharmaceutical industry herself, she says that lobbying against harm-reduction products is very well funded and effective. Nicotine replacement products are big business and in several countries, nicotine pouches and e-cigarettes are more or less banned.

"This is devastating for consumers who should have the right to choose how they use nicotine. In countries like Sweden, where most things are allowed, we see the trend going in the right direction. I come from Brazil, where e-cigarettes and other smokeless nicotine products have been completely banned. I often think about what it would have meant for my smoking father if he had just been given an honest opportunity to give up cigarettes," says Suely Castro.

Favouring the tobacco industry?

At the same time, voices in favour of harm reduction are often linked to various industrial interests. Snus advocates often sing in tune with Swedish Match (now Philip Morris), a tobacco company that has clear financial benefits to reap if smokers switch from cigs to smokeless. More recently, e-cigarettes have also become part of tobacco companies' portfolios - a fact that is not looked upon favourably in the media debate. "Favouring" tobacco companies in any way is perceived as wrong, regardless of the public health outcome.

For researchers like Fredrik Nyström, the situation is absurd. And annoying (Of course).

"For a young researcher, such accusations can ruin your whole career. But I'm done with my career now - professor and all - so I don't care if people say I'm doing someone's bidding. Because I'm not. My reasoning is based on science, evidence, experience from meetings with my patients and studies with clear statistical relevance. What else can I do, but tell you what the research clearly shows? What the hell does it matter if it 'benefits' someone here or there?" he says, annoyed.

The 'smoke-free' became the 'nicotine-free' society

When we next meet, it's at his office at Linköping university. Fredrik meets me at the entrance where I'm stuck in front of an angry sign that "becoming tobacco-free" is a piece of cake - and the staff at the university hospital can help me with that. Ten years ago, the sign would have said 'smoke-free' and nothing else. Nowadays, authorities, in collaboration with a range of government-funded lobbying organisations, have changed their focus from "smoking" to all tobacco use. Smoke-free products like snus and e-cigarettes are the 'new black' for generating subsidies: not smoking. It is perhaps no coincidence that organisations like A Non Smoking Generation, the swedish Heart and Lung Foundation and the part pharma - part tax funded Stop-Smoking-Lines are now talking more about the importance of quitting smokeless products like e-cigarettes and different forms of snus, than quitting smoking.

Better blood pressure with nicotine?

Fredrik Nyström is not involved in that particular project. And that's a good thing. His research shows that quitting snus does not necessarily lead to better health - quite the opposite.

"Blood pressure actually goes up if snus users quit. That is what the science actually reveals. Hight blood preasure can become a serious issue for some people, and to prevent this, some patients would require medication. This really raises the question of what is most appropriate: quitting snus or continuing using smoke free nicotine as usual? The fact that the National Board of Health and Welfare is urging doctors to push snus users to quit as a matter of routine, is certainly not a good policy. Have they even considered the consequences and that it may require additional measures to avoid deteriorating the patient's health? No, it doesn't seem so", says Fredrik Nyström.

As always, a little annoyed. But at least he laughs when he says it.

"Childish discussion"

One would suspect he probably doesn't get on well with his colleagues at the hospital. But Fredrik Nyström has been a practising doctor for over 30 years. Now he's decided to slow down a bit and devote more time to research - and to travelling the world to inform doctors, researchers and policy-makers about what the more down-to-earth studies actually say about the risks and benefits of smoke-free nicotine use.

"The communications department usually shudders when I come up with something," he jokes. "I know that what I say is considered controversial. But the discussion is often a bit childish, especially about what you 'can' say and what you can't. But when organisations like "A Non Smoking Generation" or even worse, the Heart-Lung Foundation would be so against the use of snus and oral nicotine? That's just silly. But of course, they live in an ecosystem where they have to say that nicotine is basically lethal to get further funding. They have to stick to their guns, regardless of what the research or evidence says. The most important thing is that politicians look at what the evidence and proper research really shows, not what various interest groups say."

"Become like a cult"

In Fredrik Nyström's world, not everything is black and white. And he notes, somewhat dryly, that reality is not always fairly reflected in black newspaper headlines that "warns of the new risks of nicotine" or "fatty fast food". From his perspective, similar headlines and anrratives appear when it comes to all lifestyle phenomena - from tobacco and nicotine to diet and exercise.

"Those who have strong opinions about your lifestyle become almost like a cult in the end. It doesn't matter what the research - the good research - shows. The anti-tobacco movement, the "Exercise youe ass off" filosofers and "Eat low-fat" evangialists won't change anyway. The problem is that these thinkers often work for government agencies and hand out general advice here and there. It's crazy. It's certainly not good for everyone to exercise all the time, maybe they should take it a little easier. It's not generally good to eat a low-fat diet, maybe some people should eat more fat and less carbohydrates. It's not good for everyone to give up snus or vaping either, for that matter. But it is good if they stay smoke-free and feel content doing this. If nicotine fulfils that function, we shouldn't keep pushing people in the wrong direction."

Nicotine works differently for everyone

Fredrik Nyström appears from time to time in both TV programmes and articles in swedish media. If it's not appeaering on national television, he turns up in various panels in Almedalen (an annual swedish event where politicians mingle and meet with industry, ngo;s and people in general). During the year he is publishing and promoting his his book and in the autumn he will appear in a number of Swedish and international contexts as the Swedish nicotine expert. He does not use nicotine himself. But he tries.

"Yes, I actually try to enjoy a traditional snus or a nicotine pouch sometimes. Tried vapes too. And of course it's good and tastes nice. I like cigars too. But I don't seem to be of the calibre to become addicted. Which is also something we see in the research. Not everyone who uses nicotine is equally addicted. Some don't seem to be addicted at all, they can just stop at any time. For others, it's the opposite, it's really hard. So it's important not to talk about addiction as if it's the same for everyone. It isn't. Just like all nicotine products are not equally harmful. But I am equally disappointed every time I realise that my medical students, people I have trained for years have not managed to learn that particular lesson."

Sighs Fredrik Nyström.
Again, a little annoyed.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *